Why Your Afternoon Cup of Coffee Might Not Work

Why Doesn't Caffeine Affect Me

It’s a long work day, and you’ve just finished the first sprint at the office. While your coworkers all load up on caffeine for the second half of the day, you get that afternoon cup of coffee yourself. However, while they seem to be rejuvenated and energized once they finish theirs, you don’t feel any different. 

Does this sound familiar? If it does, you might be one of the unlucky people whose bodies don’t respond to caffeine in the same way it does for most people. The physical and psychological short-term benefits of caffeine are widely documented, but the sad reality is that it might not affect everyone equally. 

In this article, I have outlined the reasons why coffee, or any other caffeine filled liquid for that matter, might not work in the way that it does for the people around you.

What I Learned

It took two whole decades to figure out why. I hope to spare you that same hassle, but of course, must note that this article should not substitute for the advice of your health care provider.

In short, I surprisingly learned that our individual response to caffeine is determined largely by our genetics. Click here if you want to skip down and quickly learn how to test your own caffeine genetics.

How Caffeine Affects Your Body

How Caffeine Affects the Body

Not just in coffee, caffeine occurs naturally in many plants and fruits, including of course coffee beans, but also tea leaves, cacao pods, and kola nuts (the ingredient in cola sodas). It is also chemically synthesized and added to foods, beverages, and even medications. While caffeine does not have any nutritional value, it can cause powerful physical and psychological effects that have created whole new markets: think energy drinks, pre-workout supplements, and even caffeinated water!

  • Caffeine is a central nervous system stimulant that can help you feel more alert and prevent drowsiness. However, in large amounts or due to genetics, it can make you feel anxious, jittery, and disrupt sleep. (Tip: Closely read labels of food, drinks, and supplements to make sure there is no hidden caffeine you are unintentionally consuming)
  • Caffeine temporarily increases heart rate and blood pressure, which increases the amount of oxygenated blood circulating throughout the body. This can temporarily improve endurance and reflexes similar to the body’s natural “fight or flight” response.
  • Caffeine has a complicated connection to headaches in that it can both cause and treat them. Individuals who drink lots of caffeine may experience withdrawal headaches if they quit suddenly or miss a “dose.” It may also trigger headaches in those who are particularly sensitive to its effects. Yet, caffeine is also a common ingredient in both over-the-counter and prescription migraine headache medicine.
  • One more note about caffeine withdrawal is that it can trigger mood changes, including irritability, drowsiness, and anxiety. So, if you want to cut down it is generally a good idea to reduce gradually to prevent the unpleasantness associated with stopping suddenly.

See Also: 

The Reason Why Caffeine May Not Affect You 

Caffeine Doesn't Affect Me

If you don’t get your desired effects on energy from caffeine, don’t worry, there may be a few explanations.

The Caffeine Genes

What I found is that how our unique body responds to caffeine is determined by our genetics.

That’s right, your DNA may determine whether that afternoon cup of coffee wakes you up and helps you finish the day strong…or gives you the jitters…or does nothing at all!

A team from the Harvard School of Public Health looked at the results of approximately 24 studies involving more than 120,000 people. They were able to locate eight genetic variants connected to caffeine consumption. Six of the variants were connected to genes that control how caffeine is metabolized by the body or how caffeine stimulates the body. Two genes connected with cholesterol and blood sugar may also play a role in how you respond to caffeine, but it is unclear why.

Two genes, CYP1A2 and ADORA2A, appeared to have the largest impact on how caffeine affects us:

CYP1A2, this gene determines how your body metabolizes (or breaks down) caffeine.

  • If you metabolize it fast, you are more likely to receive the desired energy boost without jitters or nervousness
  • If you metabolize it slowly, it stays in your system longer and may cause more jitters or negative effects

ADORA2A, this gene determines how caffeine acts on your brain.

  • Different variants of this gene impact whether that afternoon cup of coffee help you become more alert or explain why it has no effect
  • This gene also influences the effects of caffeine on your sleep quality, and even if its consumption makes you anxious

By now you are probably thinking, this science lesson is great but what you really want is…

The Simple Genetic Test to Understand How Caffeine Affects You

When I first found out I was a slow caffeine metabolizer it was through the popular 23andme genetic test. Unfortunately, this testing service stopped reporting on caffeine metabolism in 2016.

Luckily, there are newer (and more useful) tests to help you understand your genes and the influence they have on how caffeine affects you. The one that specifically provides insight into caffeine is the MyDNA Personalized Nutrition & Fitness Plus Caffeine test kit (amazon link also in the image below).

It tests CYP1A2 and ADORA2A which may finally help you understand why caffeine has a different effect on you. As a bonus, the test provides a whole list of other actionable health insights, including:

  • Your immune system
  • Optimal foods to eat for your unique genetics
  • The best workouts to achieve your fitness goals

For the cost of going out for coffee for a few weeks (that may not even work!), you get an impressive amount of insights and tools that can help improve your overall health and well-being.

The Effects of Excess Consumption

A study conducted by researchers from the University of Bristol in Great Britain looked at the effects of caffeine on alertness in heavy, low, and non-caffeine users after going without caffeine for 16 hours. Both the low and heavy caffeine users reported feeling more alert after taking caffeine pills; however, their level of alertness was no higher than the non-caffeine users that had received placebos. Heavy caffeine users taking the placebo were the least alert of those studied.

The researchers concluded that these results showed that caffeine actually did not raise overall alertness. The effect that the low and heavy caffeine users felt was actually a reversal of withdrawal symptoms brought on by going without caffeine for so long. The caffeine simply restored them to a normal level of alertness experienced with regular caffeine use.

The heavy caffeine drinkers receiving the placebo also reported headaches. In some cases, the headaches were so severe that the individuals had to drop out of the study. These results highlight that caffeine is not a “one size fits all” compound to improve alertness and that in some cases it may have a negative effect through dependence and withdrawal symptoms.

Finally, other factors, including body mass, age, and other health conditions can affect tolerance to caffeine. So, if you also experience side effects from the use of  (or lack of use of ) caffeine, in addition to exploring your genetics, a discussion with a healthcare provider can be useful to develop a plan on how to best consume caffeine safely.

Cutting Down on Caffeine

If you’ve spent every day for a few years loading your body up with caffeine, it might be difficult to shake the habit. Too much caffeine can be harmful to your physical and mental wellbeing in the long term. However, there are ways in which you can cut down, if not completely remove caffeine from your diet. 

An important step is to cut down on foods and drinks that might be unintentionally adding to your caffeine intake for the day. This includes energy drinks and colas, as the sugar and caffeine in these drinks can add up quickly. 

Another step you can take is to gradually reduce your intake. You don’t have to quit coffee cold turkey, but you can certainly water it down a little, drink it less often, and try switching to decaf coffee to help you kick the habit. You might feel some lethargy for the first few days, but it will definitely get better once your body gets used to the lower daily doses of caffeine. 

The Bottom Line

For a lot of people, coffee is a non-negotiable part of the day. They use it to wake up in the morning or they use an afternoon cup of coffee to get them through the day. However, there are a number of factors that can influence how caffeine affects you both physically and psychologically. 

Another thing you need to consider while loading up on caffeine is that, like all things you consume, you should know how to strike a balance. Caffeine addiction is a real thing, and there might come a point where you have to consume enough caffeine during the day just to function at your normal levels of alertness. 

I hope that this article has helped you get a good idea of why you might notice a difference between you and other people after consuming a cup of coffee. If you’re interested in similar topics, feel free to check out the other articles on this website!

Latte vs Cappuccino vs Macchiato: A Comparison For Coffee Enthusiasts

Latte vs Cappuccino vs Macchiato

If you are confused by all of the different terms on the menu of your local coffeehouse, you are not alone. If you have a hard time telling your cappuccino from your latte, the following guide will provide you with the basic knowledge that you need to order your favorite coffee drink with confidence. What Are the Differences Between a … Read more

The Best Decaf K Cup Coffee Pods For 2021: Top 18 Options


Even if you’re a committed coffee fan, sometimes it’s nice to have a decaf on hand, especially if it’s later in the day and you want to ensure your sleep won’t be disturbed. Overdoing your caffeine intake can not only lead to a damaged sleep schedule but also cause other effects like increased anxiety and an irregular heartbeat. Also, even … Read more

The Best Ground Coffee For 2021: Top 20 Options


While there’s no substitute for the sheer convenience of ground coffee, before we get started today, we’d like to slip in a qualification… If you insist on the very best from your coffee, you should buy and grind your own beans. This does require a little effort and you’ll need to invest in a grinder – check out our guide … Read more

The Best Offerings in Instant Decaf Coffee: 12 Options For 2021

For those who love the taste of coffee but who do not want a caffeine overload, the coffee offerings have traditionally been somewhat limited and less than desirable. Most of the widely available decaf coffees tended to be somewhat bitter with an underlying sourness that was less than pleasant. See Aslo:  Top 13 Best Nespresso Machines The Best Instant Coffee: … Read more

The Best Cappuccino and Latte Machines


Espresso is all well and good but it’s not an all-day drink. How about when you want to switch to longer and creamier latte or cappuccino instead? Well, luckily you won’t need a separate machine if you roll with any of the models we break down for you today. All these coffee makers come with a great frother so you can get your drink … Read more

The 12 Best Automatic Espresso Machines


If you’re looking to make coffee the easy way, an automatic espresso machine can offer far more than just short, strong shots. We’ve curated a selection of more than 10 of the finest models on the market targeting all taste and price-points. We’ll also guide you through the differences between these machines and we’ll also help you to dial in … Read more

The Best Coffee and Espresso Maker Combo


People interested in purchasing an espresso machine are quite often intimidated. Espresso machines tend to be complicated to operate, especially for a beginner. They are also expensive, and espresso machines for the home can take up a lot of room into the bargain. For these reasons, people shy away from buying espresso machines that could actually be great for them. … Read more

Infographic: How Much Coffee Will Kill You?

How Much Coffee Kill You

Just how much is too much of a good thing? We’re often warned about the dangers of excessive coffee drinking but don’t see the numbers to support this. And to be specific, it’s not the coffee but the caffeine inside it that’s dangerous. Coffee is addictive and some people can’t get through their mornings without it. Here is a chart … Read more

The Best Single Serve Coffee Makers


If you’re hunting for a new coffee machine, confusion might already have set in… Maybe you fancy giving the pour-over method a try but you haven’t got the time or the patience for a dripper. If you prize speed and the ultimate in push-button convenience, why not try a single serve coffee maker? Top 7 Best Keurig Coffee Makers Top … Read more

The Best Espresso Beans

Best Espresso Beans of 2016

Espresso beans are coffee beans that have been pressed and dark roasted to make espresso. The dark roast gives espresso its distinctive bold and bitter flavor. Any variety of coffee bean can be pressed to make espresso, but there are certain qualities that you should keep in mind to make sure that your next cup is as enjoyable as possible. … Read more

The Best Vacuum Insulated Coffee Mugs


If you’ve got a busy lifestyle and you always seem to be on the go, that morning coffee is crucial to set you up for the day but you’ll need to keep your drink warm. While a full-sized thermos might be great when you’re camping, it’s far too bulky when you’re on the morning commute. Luckily, vacuum insulated coffee mugs … Read more

How Much Coffee For 1, 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12, 30, 40 Cups?

How Much Coffee For 1, 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12 Cups?

Unlike the rest of her family, Mary wasn’t a coffee drinker. She couldn’t fathom why anyone would swig the bitter brew voluntarily. As she pushed her shopping cart past the aromatic bags of exotic-sounding blends, she halted. What in the world would her family like? It was the first Thanksgiving she’d be hosting the entire family since she’d bought her … Read more

The Best Small Espresso Machines


Small espresso machine are not hard to find but it’s tiresome hunting through to find out the exact size of each machine. That’s why we’ve done the hard yards for you. Each of the powerful machines below comes with both weight and dimensions clearly labelled. You’ll be able to compare these machines at a glance. With size taken care of, … Read more

The Story of Coffee: From Bean to Barista

The Story of Coffee: From Bean to Barista

The Ethiopian goatherd Kaldi had never seen his goats so playful. Could it be that the cherry-laden shrubbery was contributing to their energy? He bit into the crimson-cloaked seeds and immediately knew he’d hit on something revolutionary. His sight was clearer, his tiredness was gone, and his mind was alert. See Aslo:  Top 10 Best Coffee Beans For Espresso The … Read more

The Percolator: A Retro Choice for Brewing Coffee

The Percolator A Retro Choice for Brewing Coffee

Once the standard method of brewing coffee, percolators faded from popularity starting in the 1970s with the advent of drip and single-use coffee makers. Percolators are starting to make a comeback among those craving a bit of nostalgia or who like their coffee rich and full-bodied. They are still commonly used at church and other gatherings where large amounts of … Read more

How to Drink Espresso Like an Italian


Especially if you’ve visited Italy and you are now sitting and drinking an espresso in one of the cafes in Florence or Rome, you can keep reading for how to drink espresso like an Italian and get approval from the locals who take their espresso so seriously. First, know the basics.  Machines used in making espresso use 132 lb. per … Read more

The Best Italian Espresso Machines


Espresso is definitely not made in the same way you make a simple cup of coffee. For starters, you need to use coffee beans that are of premium quality. No generic bargain bin bags here, you need the good stuff. These high-quality beans also need to be processed into super-fine grounds. You also can’t brew espresso in your countertop coffeepot. Espresso needs … Read more

Do Not Let Stale Coffee Ruin Your Morning Cup of Joe

If you are purchasing a commercial brand of pre-ground coffee from your local grocery store, proper storage technique and preserving freshness is probably not a major concern. On the other hand, if you are shelling out $20 to $30 for just a half-pound of gourmet coffee beans, you need to treat them right to guarantee that you get the most … Read more

The Best Coffee Scales


As an avid coffee fan, you may spend thousands of dollars on the highest quality brewing equipment. This can include multiple grinders and brewing jugs. However, that’s not all! You may invest your time as well, trying to learn about the best methods for brewing different kinds of coffee. Imagine the irony when you use a cheap plastic scoop to … Read more