The Best Dog Training Collar Reviews

best-dog-training-collars

If you’re looking for the best dog training collar, you might initially be overwhelmed with what’s a surprisingly busy market segment.

Firstly, you’ll encounter many names that all amount to the same thing. Whether you see them labelled as electric dog training collars, e-collars, shock collars or remote training collars, the core purpose remains the same: training your dog to behave better and not to bark excessively.

See Also:

In today’s collection of 20 shock collar reviews, we’ve got a variety of styles and types across all price-points so there’s truly something for everyone. We’ll launch right in with our dog training collar reviews then we’ll double down on some handy hints for getting the most from this highly effective training method.

Whether you want to train your canine with beeps, vibration, spray or static shock, read on…


I. Top 20 Best Dog Training Collar Reviews

1) The Best Dog Training Collar: SportDOG Family Remote Trainers

SportDOG-Brand-425-Family-Remote-Trainers

When it comes to training collars for dogs, SportDOG comes out at the top of almost every list and with just cause.

Offering a range of up to 500 yards, these training collars are ideal for sporting dogs. You can also connect a single remote with a trio of different collars (available separately) allowing you to train 3 pups at once.

With 2 different deterrent options, you can opt for the one that works best for your dog. Choose from a quick stimulation to get the attention of your dog, or a longer continuous stimulation to correct ongoing poor behavior.

The battery has a long life lasting between 50 and 70 hours and charging is brisk at less than 2 hours. Battery indicators on both the collar and the control alert you when it’s time for a burst of juice.

The collar is submergible up to 25 feet making this collar a waterproof and solid training ally.

If you’re interested in the SportDOG brand but really need a collar to train your hunting dog, look no further. SportDOG has you covered there, too with the best Hunting Dog Training Collar.
Pros

  • Suitable for almost all dogs
  • Differentiation in stimulation ranges
  • Able to use to train multiple dogs

Cons

  • You need to keep the collar fairly tight to be effective

2) Best Waterproof Dog Training Collar: Dogtra Fieldmaster LCD Training Collar

Dogtra-Fieldmaster-1-Dog-LCD-Training-Collar

Dogtra brings the Fieldmaster LCD model to the table with several configurations sure to please!

Both the controller and the collar for the Fieldmaster from Dogtra are fully submersible and waterproof.

There are over 25 different stimulation levels to choose from to help you train your pup and they can be adjusted to be felt as a momentary nick to catch your dog’s attention, a constant electrical stimulation to correct your pup, or as a vibration that is not too stimulating.

Should you get separated from your canine, the controller transmits to the collar even when they are a half a mile apart.

The controller features an LCD screen that lets you know what level of stimulation the collar is on, as well as keeping you informed of the battery life of the collar. The battery is rechargeable and charges quickly.
Pros

  • Lengthy battery life
  • Both components are completely waterproof
  • LCD screen makes training simple

Cons

  • The collar is adjustable but if you’ve got a smaller dog there will be a lot of slack that needs to be dealt with

Top 13 Best Anti-Bark Collars


3) Best Multi-Dog Training Collar: Educator E-Collar

Educator-ET-302-Two-Dog-Mini-1/2-Mile-E-Collar-Remote-Dog-Training-Collar-With-Vibration

If you’re in the process of training multiple dogs at once, you’re probably looking for something to make this task a bit simpler. Educator E-Collar rides to your rescue with this fantastic collar for training more than one dog at a time.

The Educator system transmits signal up to half a mile so you can still get your pup’s attention even if they’ve run off a little. There’s also an option that can transmit up to three-quarters of a mile should you anticipate the need for some extra latitude.

The transmitter is similar to a stopwatch. It’s small and can fit in the palm of your hand allowing for ease of use for anyone with smaller hands.

The collars are compact enough for a small dog but the stimulator still packs a punch when needed. There are 100 different levels of stimulation that can be used to train your pup. In addition to the electrical stimulation, there’s also a tapping non-stimulating sensation.

The batteries will be fully charged in 2 hours but will need charging daily.
Pros

  • Small transmitter and stimulator
  • Useful for training multiple dogs
  • Light on the collar to help with tracking at night

Cons

  • Short battery life

Top 6 Best Bark Collars With Remote


4) Best No-Shock Collar: PetSafe Remote Spray Trainer

PetSafe-Remote-Spray-Trainer,-Training-Collar-and-Remote-for-Dogs-8-lb.-and-Up

Some dogs don’t respond well to shock training but owners still need to find a suitable method of training. Thankfully, PetSafe has developed this Remote Spray Trainer for just that kind of situation.

There are 3 different stimulation options with this collar. You can choose from spray, vibration, or tone.

The refillable cartridges used for the spray stimulation come in unscented and citronella versions and each cartridge can spray up to 35 times.

The vibration option will vibrate against your pup and can be useful for training.

The tone variant will emit a tone only your pup can hear and when you catch their attention you can work on training them.

Perfect for dogs 8 pounds and up, this collar is water resistant and the signal transmits up to 300 yards.

The collar has indicators for a low spray as well as a low battery. It charges quickly and holds a charge for around 40 hours.
Pros

  • Remote is backlit making it easy to use at night
  • No-shock training system is a better option for some people and dogs
  • Easy to use even for complete beginners

Cons

  • The buttons on the remote are extremely sensitive

Top 10 Best Bark Collar for Small Dogs


5) Best Budget: Dog Care Dog Training Collar

Dog-Training-Collar-Rechargeable-Dog-Shock-Collar-w/3-Training-Modes,-Beep,-Vibration-and-Shock

Having pets and properly caring for them can quickly become expensive, but they still need to be well-trained. Fortunately, Dog Care is aware of the cost associated with training pups and worked hard to bring about a great budget option available for dog training collars.

These collars can be used to train up to 9 dogs using 3 different training modes. There’s a beep mode, vibration mode, and shock mode. The shock mode also provides you with nearly 100 different levels of intensity ensuring you can adjust the level to wherever your pup responds.

The collars are adjustable and can fit dogs from 15 to 100 pounds. The receiver on the collar is waterproof.

The wireless controller reaches up to 330 yards, and features a lock pad that means there’s no way for you to accidentally shock your pup.

Both the receiver and the transmitter are rechargeable and the battery has an impressive lifespan of up to 15 days on the receiver and 45 days on the transmitter.
Pros

  • Can use for several dogs
  • Long-reaching signal
  • Impressive battery life

Cons

  • Transmitter is kind of bulky

Top 7 Best Citronella Bark Collars


6) PetSafe Yard and Park Rechargeable Training Collar

PetSafe-Yard-&-Park-Rechargeable-Dog-Training-Collar-with-Tone-and-Static-Correction

Another fantastic offering from PetSafe is this Yard and Park Training Collar.

With the purchase of additional collars, this transmitter can be used to train 3 dogs at once. The transmitter’s signal reaches up to 400 yards so you can be sure your pup will almost never be out of range of correction or redirection from you.

Useful for training indoors, in the yard, or at the park, this is a great collar for any dog owner.

The collar fits dogs that from 8 pounds and upward and it can be adjusted to fit necks that to 28 inches.

The receiver on the collar is waterproof and there are 8 levels of adjustable intensity for training and correction purposes. There are both stimulation levels as well as tone levels to be used for different types of training methods.

Both the collar and the transmitter have rechargeable batteries as well.
Pros

  • Signal reaches a great distance
  • Useful for training multiple pups
  • Several settings to choose from

Cons

  • Battery life is underwhelming

7) PetTech PT0Z1 Premium Dog Training Collar

PetTech-PT0Z1-Premium-Dog-Training-Shock-Collar

If you want to work as a professional dog trainer or handler then this is the training collar for you. It works just as well for everyday pet owners needing to effectively train their pups, too.

Thought his collar can only be used for 1 dog, it still makes a smart choice. You’ve got multiple training settings to choose from. These modes can be used to achieve different goals through training.

Light mode helps with training when it is dark, beep mode is useful for training your dog on a leash, vibration mode is good for obedience training, and shock mode is helpful for other situations.

Both the vibration and static shock modes have 100 different levels of customization ensuring you get what you need to effectively train your pup.

The collar is adjustable and will fit any pup over 10 pounds.

The transmitter remote features a backlit LCD screen allowing it to be used day and night. The transmitter has a range of up to 400 yards.

Both the collar and the remote have long-lasting rechargeable batteries.
Pros

  • Includes professional training help
  • Multiple training modes and settings to choose from
  • Lengthy signal range

Cons

  • Can only be used for 1 dog

8) Garmin Sport PRO Bundle

Garmin-Sport-PRO-Bundle,-Dog-Training-Collar-and-Handheld

Garmin is a well-known provider of electronic products that help make life easier so it only makes sense they’ve developed a dog training collar to help pet owners, too.

This Sport PRO Bundle features a collar and transmitter that have a signal range of three -quarters of a mile. This set is perfect for training a sporting or hunting dog.

With additional collar purchases, this set can be used to train 3 dogs simultaneously, making your life even easier.

The collar is adjustable and works for almost all pups. Each receiver has 10 different levels of stimulation and can this can carried out in both a static mode or a tone and vibration mode. There are LED beacon lights on the collar as well allowing visibility even in low light.

The transmitter is simple to use and it can be operated with 1 hand. Using a dial, you can select between training modes as well as levels of stimulation.

This collar also features a BarkLimiter, allowing you to train your pup to keep the volume down when necessary.
Pros

  • Beacon light lets you keep an eye on your dog
  • BarkLimiter for training your dog to quit barking
  • Different training modes and levels of stimulation

Cons

  • Poor battery life

9) Dogtra 1 Dog Training Collar System (3/4-Mile Range)

Dogtra-1900S-3/4-Mile-Range-1-Dog-Training-Collar-System

We’ve looked at a collar from Dogtra already on this list but they offer plenty of choices when it comes to dog training collars so we’ve got another up next.

This model from Dogtra has a reach of up to three-quarters of a mile allowing it to stand out from the pack. This long reach is ideal if you’re training a sporting or hunting dog, or even if you need your pup to obey you in a large park.

With additional collars, this model can be used to train 2 dogs at once.

The collar is adjustable, but is meant more for medium to large dogs with the smallest suggested weight being 35 pounds.

The receiver is fully waterproof so you don’t have to worry about it breaking when your pup jumps in the lake.

Because all pups are different and will respond in their own way, there are 127 different stimulation levels on the collar. Also, battery charge time on the receiver is a short 2 hours allowing you to get back to work in no time.
Pros

  • 2-hour quick charge battery
  • Can be used to train two dogs
  • Long reaching signal

Cons

  • Not useable for smaller dogs

10) Petrainer Rainproof Dog Shock Collar

Petrainer-PET998DRB-Rainproof-Dog-Shock-Collar-with-Remote-Dog-Training-Collar-with-Beep-Vibrate-Shock-Electronic-Collar

Petrainer is another fabulous company offering many different models of dog training collars. This specific model is used and loved by professional dog trainers and everyday pet owners alike.

With a reach of over 300 yards, you can train your dog to be obedient in a park or in the back yard.

The collar features 3 different training modes: shock, vibration, and beep. All are useful for different situations, and all can be customized through up to 100 different levels of intensity.

The contact points of the receiver also have soft silicone covers to ensure your pup’s skin isn’t irritated. Also, the collar is rainproof so no worries if you get caught in an unexpected shower.

The transmitter is easily operated with simple to use buttons and it features an LED backlit screen so you can clearly see the settings and battery life.

With a quick charge time of 2 hours, you and your pup can be back to playing and training before you know it!
Pros

  • Multiple training modes and settings
  • Silicone covers for contact points
  • Rainproof receiver

Cons

  • Can’t be used to train multiple dogs

11) Petrainer Dog Shock Collar with Remote

Petrainer-PET619A1-Dog-Shock-Collar-with-Remote-100%-Waterproof-Dog-Training-Collar

Another fantastic model from Petrainer is this Shock Collar with Remote. Highly affordable, you’ll enjoy plenty of control over your training situation.

As with most models from Petrainer, this one has a reach of over 300 yards. The signal from the transmitter can easily reach through walls as well. This allows you to effectively train your pup in almost any circumstances.

The collar is adjustable and made for pups weighing at least 15 pounds. The receiver is 100 percent waterproof as well. With 3 different training modes including static, vibration, and tone, you can find the one that best works for your pup. Beyond this, there are 100 intensity levels so you can provide the most efficient level of stimulation for your pup’s training purposes.

The transmitter is simple to use featuring easy to read buttons and a dial for adjustment. Because it is so easily operated, Petrainer and users refer it to it as “Blind Operation”.

The receiver and transmitter are both rechargeable, and as always, the charger features Petrainer’s quick-charge functionality.
Pros

  • 2-hour quick charge
  • Designed to ensure there are no accidental shocks
  • 100% waterproof

Cons

  • The battery dies quickly

12) Garmin Delta XC Bundle

Garmin-Delta-XC-Bundle---dog-training-device

Another life-simplifying option from Garmin, this Delta bundle is sure to please both the casual dog owner and the professional trainer.

With a range of over a half-mile, you can use this system to train your pup in your own backyard or even while out in the field or in a large park.

With the purchase of supplementary collars, this device can be used to train 3 dogs simultaneously.

The receiver on the collar has 3 different training configurations including tone, vibrate, and shock. There are also 18 different intensity levels that can be administered momentarily or continuously depending on how your pup best responds.

The contact points can also be changed to work better depending on your dog’s coat.

The transmitter is extremely simple to use with just 3 buttons and an LCD display screen.

Both components feature rechargeable batteries.
Pros

  • Components are well-made
  • Easy to use
  • Can be used for multiple dogs

Cons

  • Not the best option for high-drive dogs

13) Dogtra Remote Training Collar (3/4-Mile Range)

Dogtra-1900S-/-1902S-Remote-Training-Collar

This set gives you almost all you need to effectively train your pup as you would fully expect from a company like Dogtra.

You will get not only the transmitter, collar and receiver but also a PetsTEK training clicker. These are a great option for almost all dogs and they provide another mode of training.

The signal features a range of up to three-quarters of a mile ensuring that whether you are training your pup in the yard or in on open field, you can command his full attention. It doesn’t matter if your dog has a mild temperament or is especially stubborn, this collar can work for them.

The collar will fit dogs weighing at least 35 pounds with necks up to 26 inches.

The receiver on the collar can be adjusted to be used in several ways including a momentary nick, a constant static stimulation mode, or a non-stimulating vibration mode. The intensity can be adjusted to 127 different levels, as well.

The screen of the transmitter keeps you apprised of battery status as well as the training mode.

Both the collar and receiver are waterproof and both feature rapid charge lithium batteries.
Pros

  • Extra training equipment thrown in
  • Long-traveling signal range
  • Waterproof components

Cons

  • Not meant for smaller dogs

14) Dogtra IQ-PLUS Remote Trainer

Dogtra-IQ-PLUS-Remote-Trainer

Dogtra’s IQ-Plus is slightly different than the competition in a few key ways.

To start with, this model of dog training collar is ideal for dogs as small as 10 pounds in weight. The collar is tiny, though it’s still adjustable to fit your specific pup. Also, the receiver on the collar is a bit less powerful.

There are 3 different modes, including nick, constant, and vibration. These modes can be adjusted through 100 varying levels of intensity.

The signal range on this model is up to 400 yards which will allow you to work on training your pup in just about any location. The transmitter has a blue LCD screen that allows you to see stimulation levels as well as remaining battery life.

Both the receiver and the transmitter have rechargeable batteries, and they can be ready for use in as little as 2 hours.
Pros

  • Great option for smaller dogs
  • Waterproof receiver
  • Rapid charge batteries

Cons

  • Battery doesn’t seem to last very long between charges

15) BOIFUN Dog Training Collar with Remote

Advanced-Dog-Training-Collar-W/Remote-for-Small-Medium-Large-Dogs

Purchasing a dog training collar from BOIFUN will guarantee you’re getting a quality product and results to match.

This model can transmit and receive signals up to 1000 feet away so you can get your dog’s attention quickly. With the purchase of additional collars, you can train up to 9 dogs simultaneously.

The receiver features 3 training modes including beep, vibration, and static shock. All are useful in different situations, and it’s ideal to have a choice so you can see what works most effectively with your pup. The intensity can be adjusted from low to high through 99 different levels of stimulation.

The transmitter is small and easy to handle. There are lock and unlock settings as well ensuring you can’t accidentally shock your dog.

The batteries in the receiver and the collar charge within 3 hours and have an impressive battery life boasting a standby time of up to 40 days.
Pros

  • Long battery life
  • Can be used for 9 dogs
  • Several options for training purposes

Cons

  • Instructions aren’t clear, making operation a bit tricky

16) Dog Care Dog Training Collar

DOG-CARE-Dog-Training-Collar---Upgrated-Dog-Shock-Collar

Dog Care has already made our list as a great budget option, and they make another appearance with this powerful dog-training collar.

If you opt to buy additional collars, this transmitter can be used to train 9 different pups simultaneously. With a signal range of 330 yards, you can work with your pup in the backyard or at the park without any problems.

The collar is adjustable for dogs from 15 to 100 pounds. The receiver is 100% waterproof and has 3 different training options.

Choose from beep mode, vibration mode, or static shock mode. The static shock mode can also be adjusted to 100 different levels of intensity so you can find the one that is most effective for your pup’s training needs.

The transmitter also features a keylock that prevents you from accidentally shocking your dog.

Both the transmitter and the receiver are rechargeable and have great battery lifespans. The remote can last up to 45 days while the receiver can last up to 15 days.
Pros

  • Can be used for up to 9 dogs
  • Waterproof receiver
  • Long range signal

Cons

  • The receiver is very large and can be cumbersome on your dog

17) Nemobub Dog Shock Collar with Remote

Nemobub-Dog-Shock-Collar-1600ft-Remote-Training-and-100%-Waterproof

The collar and receiver of this Nemobub have a signal range of over 300 yards, allowing you to train your dog anywhere from the park to open fields or even in the backyard.

This model features the 3 modes most commonly found in dog training collars (beep, vibrate, and static shock). The transmitter allows you to adjust the intensity of these modes through 100 different levels so you can effectively train your pup as needed.

The 3 colorful buttons allow you to easily choose which mode you would like to use while the adjuster buttons allow you to customize the intensity. The LCD screen keeps you up to date on the battery life remaining as well.

The collar will fit dogs ranging from 10 pounds to 110 pounds and can adjust from 7 inches to 26 inches. The receiver is waterproof and the conductors are covered in a silicone sleeve.

Both components feature rechargeable batteries.
Pros

  • Long lasting battery
  • Fits a range of dogs
  • Several different options for training

Cons

  • Unable to be used for multiple dogs

18) Petronics Rechargeable Shock Training Collar

Petronics-Rechargeable-Shock-Training-Collar-with-Remote

Another affordably priced option on our list list comes from Petronics. This rechargeable dog-training collar is a great choice whether you’re a professional trainer or just a regular pet owner.

When training your pup, you will likely need to work in a variety of situations, and this collar can help you do just that. With a signal range of over 300 yards, you can be sure your pup will obey just about anywhere.

Though this collar won’t be suitable for smaller dogs, it can be adjusted to fit a wide range of medium and large breed pups. The collar can be shortened or lengthened to fit dog necks from 14 to 23 inches.

The receiver has 4 different functions including light, beep, vibration and shock. All of these are useful for different training scenarios. With the static shock function, you can also select from 100 different levels of intensity.

The transmitter remote is easily operated with just a few different buttons and an LED screen that allows you to know which mode you are using as well as the intensity level, and it also keeps you updated on the battery life remaining.

The receiver and the transmitter are both rechargeable as well.
Pros

  • Collar allows for a lot of adjustment in length
  • 4 useful training functions
  • Remote is simple to use

Cons

  • This collar is not waterproof

19) TBI Pro Dog Training Collar with Remote

All-New-2019-Dog-Training-Collar-with-Remote-|-Long-Range-1600',-Shock,-Vibration-Control,-Rechargeable-&-Ipx7-Waterproof

With one of the best signal ranges on the market, this dog-training collar from TBI is a solid choice if you’re working with a sporting dog or a hunting dog.

When you are training for a certain purpose, like hunting, it’s imperative that your dog be able to run free but still obey commands. This training collar has an impressive signal range of 1600 feet allowing for that to happen.

The receiver operates across 4 different modes including beep, vibration, and static shock. The shock setting can be adjusted to 100 different intensity levels allowing you to leave it where it is most effective for your training purposes.

Also, the receiver is 100% waterproof. The collar can be adjusted to fit pups from 10 to 100 pounds.

The transmitter remote has a few buttons that allow you to operate the receiver on the collar. There is also a screen on the remote that tells you what mode you are using as well as the intensity level. This also displays the battery level.

The receiver and the remote both have rechargeable batteries.
Pros

  • Incredibly long signal range
  • 4 training modes
  • Will fit most dogs

Cons

  • The screen isn’t lighted, so it can be difficult to see what you are doing

20) Casfuy Training Collar with Remote

Casfuy-Training-Collar-Upgraded-1000ft-Remote-Waterproof-Rechargeable-Dog-Shock-Collar

Casfuy is a company with plenty of experience when it comes to training dogs so this collar makes a fitting end to our list.

With a 300-yard range, this collar should be plenty to train your pup. You can also purchase an additional collar so that you can train 2 dogs with one transmitter remote.

There are 3 different training modes including beep, vibration, and static shock. You can adjust the stimulation of the shock through 100 different intensities so you can get it to wherever your pup responds effectively to your commands. The receiver is also waterproof.

The transmitter remote has easy to use color-coded buttons. With this, you can quickly select from the 3 modes and also adjust the intensity.

There’s a backlit LCD screen that displays key data. You can see the intensity level of the mode you are on along with the battery life remaining on the collar and the remote.

The batteries in the receiver as well as the remote are rechargeable.
Pros

  • Fits most dogs
  • Can be used to train 2 dogs at once
  • Transmitter is user friendly

Cons

  • Easy to accidentally set off a shock

OK…

With that huge collection of shock collar reviews behind us, we’ll look first at whether or not using static shock as a method of correction is safe and humane…


II. Are Shock Collars Safe and Humane?

Are-Shock-Collars-Safe-and-Humane

In a word, yes.

We’re certainly not here to convince you to use this method if you’re not entirely happy and comfortable with the idea of using mild discouragement to improve your dog’s behavior. There are plenty of other options at your disposal.

How much does it really hurt your dog to use this kind of electric shock, though?

If you think about touching fingers with a friend after walking across a carpet, the level of static shock you get is roughly comparably to that administered by shock collars. It’s certainly enough to cause your dog to draw up but nowhere near enough to be considered seriously painful.

While correctly defined as the “least humane” of corrective devices by The Humane Society, this is relative. They certainly are more intrusive than a beep, vibration or spray. This does not make them either unsafe or inhumane, though.

As long as you regularly clean your dog’s neck, use the collar in full accordance with the instructions and don’t object to the concept of delivering a minor shock to your dog, a shock collar can be remarkably effective.


III. Things to Look For When Buying Dog Training Collar

Things-to-Look-For-When-Buying-Dog-Training-Collar

There are a wide variety of dog training collars available on the market and it can be easy to get lost in all the choices, unable to decide which makes the best fit for you and your pup. As with all things, there are some options that are much better than others but each owner, dog, and situation is unique.

Because there are so many choices, we’ve compiled a list of factors that count no matter the budget, the dog, or the situation.

Take the following things into consideration when you’re searching for your dog training collar and you are sure to find one that gives you years of faithful service.

Maximum Signal Range

It doesn’t matter if you’re planning on keeping your dog within your own suburban neighborhood or taking him out to the open fields to roam, you need to be sure your training collar has a sufficient range to get your pup’s attention.

Most training collars have a standard signal range of 330 yards which is about 1000 feet. This is an acceptable range for most dogs, especially if they’re just walking through the neighborhood with you.

However, if you plan to take your pup into a situation where they can distance themselves from you, you should opt for a collar that allows for that. You will also want this sort of collar if your pooch is prone to wandering off. Collars can be found with a variety of signal range options, some up to a mile.

The signal also depends on the area in which you are training or working, though. It will not be as effective in a hilly area as it is on flat city streets.

Training Modes

Every dog is different and responds to different stimuli in their own unique way. Because of this, there is no one way to effectively train a dog.

Unless you want to spend a bunch of money on several different collars, roll with one featuring multiple training modes.

Modes that are commonly found are tone, vibration, and shock.

When using the tone mode as a method of training, you would use the remote to make the collar emit a beep sound that would catch your dog’s attention.

The vibration mode works in much the same way, as the transmitter signals to the collar to vibrate on the dog’s neck.

The shock mode is one that should not be used often, but can be effective, especially for stubborn or high-drive pooches. When signaled, the receiver on the collar will emit a shock to the pup alerting them to obey you.

Some remotes and receivers give you even more control over these training modes as you can choose the length of time they are effective. You can give a quick beep, vibration, or shock or, when necessary, you can opt to have the stimulation be longer lasting.

Intensity Levels

Large breed dogs like huskies will likely need a higher level of a vibration or shock than a small Chihuahua. This is due to the size of the pup as well as the amount of fur they have on their neck.

Many of these training collars allow for this, by giving you the option to adjust the intensity level of the training stimulator.

Most give you a range of up to 100 different levels of intensity so you can find the one your pup best responds to.

Specific Needs

  • Cost: You’ll notice there’s a wide range of price points with these dog training collar. You shouldn’t feel the need to stop looking if the most expensive one available is out of your budget. There are some truly fantastic budget options available out there as well. There are also plenty of choices priced in between these extremes so no matter your budget, there’s a dog training collar available for you
  • Multiple Dogs: Many people need to have the ability to train more than 1 dog at a time, but the thought of keeping track of all those remotes is overwhelming, not to mention the sky-high cost of purchasing different sets of training collars. Thankfully, many manufacturers have developed their products in a way that makes this possible. Usually, you can purchase additional collars and they can all be operated with a single transmitter remote. Some models allow you to train as many as 10 dogs at once!
  • Sizing: Many of these dog-training collars are not meant for smaller dogs. There are a few options that can be effective but don’t try to use a collar meant for a large dog to train your small dog. Measure the circumference of your pooch’s neck to be sure the collar you’re ordering fits properly
  • Waterproofing: If you’re training your pup to be a hunting dog or if your dog likes to play in the water, you should definitely look into a waterproof model of dog training collar. There are water resistant options that are useful for getting caught in the rain but some dogs are going to need more protection than they can provide so be sure to think about that when purchasing your dog training collar
  • Control Screen: Chances are you will be training your dog during many different times of the day. You need to be able to see the controller when you are in bright sun and also in gloomy conditions. For that reason, you should look for a controller that has lighting, specifically one that’s backlit and LCD. With this variant, you can see the screen of your remote no matter what time of day it is
  • Transmitter Options: Some transmitters are easier to use than others. Be sure to look for one you can understand clearly so you don’t use the wrong training method at the wrong time. Also, look for controllers that have a lock of some sort, whether a switch or a keypad that must be unlocked. If you don’t have this option, it can be easy to accidentally shock your dog

Safety

Many people hear or see the term “shock collar” and feel disgusted. Some people don’t believe it’s a safe or humane method of training dogs while others are perfectly fine with the concept.

Truthfully, only you know what you are comfortable with. You know if using electrical stimulation is the right option for your pup or if there is another route you want to go.

There is much to be said for the safety of these dog-training collars as well.

You should be aware of certain things when using these collars to train your pup, though.

The prongs that cause the stimulation need to be kept clean. If they’re dirty, this can prevent the stimulation from being felt or even cause it to send an unintended static shock.

Water can amplify the strength of the shock. When your dog is in the pool or is wet for some reason, be sure to use other methods (tone or vibration) before resorting to the shock.

Check your dog for any signs of irritation or burns. The electrical shock can cause inflammation and other problems at the site of the shock. If the static shock option is overused or used too great an intensity level, your pup can even be burned by the prongs.


IV. Tips for Using a Dog Training Collar

When you’re using a dog collar for training purposes, it might seem like the easiest thing in the world to just slip it on and start training but there are some pointers that can make your life easier while increasing your chances of success…

Start Obedience Training Without a Collar

It’s well worth starting to train your dog without using a collar. If you find your pup is barking excessively, start out by gently discouraging him then rewarding him for compliance.

This might not work but give it a go.

With any type of behavior correction, you’re always well advised to attempt to teach your pet without the use of any device then move on to using one if you have no luck the natural way.

We’ll assume since you’re reading this that you’re still having problems so you should start by making sure you’re getting the right kind of collar…

Choose The Right Type of Collar

Look at all your different options and consider whether the idea of an ultrasonic beep, gentle vibration, a slight static shock or a citronella spray sits best with you.

Ask yourself whether you need a collar you can leave on your dog to administer correction automatically or whether you want a remote training collar for more proactive use.

Getting this element of the equation wrong will make you job so much harder. Take the time to get it right and training is likely to proceed swimmingly.

Use Positive Reinforcement

Just like when you’re trying to teach children, punishment without reward is a cruel and ineffective approach.

Be absolutely certain to accompany aversion therapy with positive reinforcement. Make it abundantly clear to your beloved dog when he’s doing well. Give him a treat, give him a hug, or stroke him.

The key is to combine correction with reward.

Beware of Over-Correction

If you see poor results, it might be tempting to use more and more correction in an attempt to jolt your dog to his senses and force him to comply. This is highly unlikely to yield dividends.

If your dog is not responding to the particular collar you’re using, it might be worth considering a different type of collar or increasing the amount of positive reinforcement you give him.

Simply amping up the correction is a poor strategy.

Make Full Use of Progressive Correction

If you’ve opted for a static shock collar, make full use of the range of settings provided. Always start out at the very bottom end and gently move on through these intensity levels.

Never get impatient and don’t suddenly increases the intensity by a huge degree. These different levels are there for a reason. Used correctly, progressive static correction can be incredibly effective.

Consider Avoiding Shock Collars with Aggressive Dogs

If your dog has an aggressive temperament, it might be tempting to imagine a strong static shock will be the best method of bringing him in line.

Counter-intuitively, this is actually not the case. In general, an aggressive dog will not respond well to negative reinforcement or high levels of shock. If anything, it’s likely to make the behavior worse rather than better.

You should consider using alternative methods and even calling in professional help if your you need to bring a super-aggressive dog to heel.

OK…

To round out, we’ve collected 5 of the most frequently asked questions about training collars.


V. FAQs

1) Will an e-collar shock your dog?

In a word, no. Not in a bad way. The level of static shock administered in a modern electronic shock collar is only in line with the static shocks you’re used to receiving yourself if you touch a person or metal object after walking across carpet. While more extreme than a beep or vibration, these collars are perfectly safe.

2) Can you use training collars on smaller dogs?

Yes. All collars come with a suggestion regarding the weight of dog the collar is suitable as well as the neck size. You can find plenty of dog collars for smaller dogs.

3) Won’t a shock collar end up making my dog even more aggressive?

They won’t if your dog is not aggressive in the first place. If they are, you’re better off using an alternative method. If your dog is not aggressive, properly administered shocks from a training collar combined with positive reinforcement should have no negative effects. At worst, the correction will not be effective.

4) Does citronella spray really work?

Absolutely! Dogs not only hate the fact they’ll get a wet nose, they also detest the citrus scent of citronella. They might not work for all dogs but the concept of spray collars is soun and many pet owners fin significant success using this method.

5) Is it necessary to use a professional dog trainer?

It isn’t unless you really want to or you have serious behavior problems you want under control. You can use all of the collars we review without any need for professional input so save some money and do it yourself!


VI. Conclusion

We very much hope today’s bumper guide will help you find the best shock collar for your needs.

With so many different types to choose from, start off by deciding on your budget. This decision alone will whittle down your options to a more manageable level and prevent analysis paralysis setting in.

Once you’re clear on pricing, think about which type of correction works best. Do you want a beep or vibration? Maybe you’d like both and that’s no problem. How about a spray? How do you feel about using static shock collars? Again, by deciding on the kind of collar that would work best for your dog, you’ll again thin out the field.

Don’t overlook the size and temperament of your dog or the location you’ll most often be training him in.

Pay close attention to our buying guide for specifics on what to look for in the best training collar and you’ll soon be noticing a marked improvement in your furball’s behavior!

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment