What’s the purpose of a thermal carafe on a coffee maker? Well, perhaps you’ve got a larger family and you want to make a substantial brew so you’re not constantly heading over to the coffee maker in the morning. Maybe you work from home and you want to ensure there’s a steady supply of coffee to hand so you don’t need to keep hitting the kettle every half-hour.
With stainless steel thermal carafes, you’ll be able to keep your coffee hotter for longer whatever your needs. A good drip brewer should have adequate capacity for your requirements. There’s no right or wrong answer here so just think closely about your family and your needs to get the most appropriate size.
- Top 13 Best Single Serve Coffee Makers
- Top 12 Best Pour Over Coffee Makers
- Top 7 Best Automatic Drip Coffee Makers
Automatic carafe coffee makers should also be easy to use and deliver a balanced and consistent cup of joe every time with minimal user input. Today, we’ll report on our extensive testing which yielded us 10 of the best thermal carafe coffee makers in a crowded market. Once we’ve outlined where these models stand and fall, we’ll give you some handy hints on what to look out for when you’re buying a coffee maker with a thermal carafe.
We’ll launch straight in now with our reviews so you can find the most fitting drip brewer the easy way…
Table of Contents
I. Top 10 Best Thermal Carafe Coffee Makers
1. Our Pick: Breville Coffee Maker with Thermal Carafe
You’ll get a great deal of flexibility with this classic Breville coffee maker…
With the thermal carafe in place, brew up to 60oz of coffee so you’ve got enough for all the family and it will stay hotter for longer. Thanks to the Steep and Release valve, you can also brew up smaller batches without the carafe in place.
You’ll get a pair of filter baskets included, one with a flat bottom and one that’s cone-shaped.
PID temperature control allows you to get your coffee just the way you like it and the range of settings allows you to tweak flow rate and bloom time to match your preferred coffee.
Operation is super-simple and if you don’t fancy fiddling with the settings, choose from 6 presets streamlining everything for you at the twist of a dial.
While the Breville is not particularly cheap, if you act quickly, you can capitalize on an aggressive discount.
Based on all categories, this hard-hitting model is our standout winner for best thermal coffee maker.
- Tech-driven interface with simple dials to operate
- My Brew system allows you to fully customize your drink just the way you like it
- Brew a full 60oz of coffee and keep it hotter for longer thanks to thermal carafe
- A few glitches with programming that could use ironing out
2. Runner-Up: Ninja Hot and Cold Brewed System
The Ninja Auto-IQ gives you a huge choice of drinks in one sleek unit.
Aside from the thermal carafe, one of the key selling points of this machine is the way you can make both hot and cold drinks. Not only can you enjoy iced coffee, you can also replicate the time-honored cold brew in just 10 to 15 minutes.
You’re spoiled for choice with brew styles including classic, rich, specialty, cold brew or over ice.
In terms of sizing, make single cups or travel mugs with equal ease or go for a full carafe when you’ve got everyone in the family crying out for coffee. That carafe keeps it warmer for longer, too so you’ll minimize waste.
You can use freshly ground beans or loose tea so you can keep expenses down and the quality of the drink in your mug up.
The Ninja gets our vote as a close runner-up for robust performance matched with unbeatable flexibility.
- Whether you want tea or coffee, hot or iced drinks, the Ninja can even extend to producing cold brew in a mere quarter-hour
- 6 brew sizes at your disposal from a single cup to a whole carafe
- Multiple brewing styles so customize your drinks completely
- Customer service can be questionable
3. Upgrade Pick: Technivorm Moccamaster Coffee Brewer
If you’ve got a more generous budget for a coffee machine and you’re looking for a tech-laden machine that makes a real conversation piece, the Technivorm Moccamaster is a modern classic.
This 40oz machine comes in 3 commanding colorways to gel with any kitchen décor.
Proper temperature is key if you’re looking for that golden cup of coffee and the Moccamaster packs a highly capable heating element to ensure speed and consistency within the ideal operating band of temperatures.
All plastic components complementing the stainless steel are free from BPA, BPS, phthalates and all other potential contaminants.
The drip system gives you the 6-minute steep required for great brewed coffee and pre-immersion to ensure the coffee blooms perfectly. It drips through into a thermal stainless steel carafe so you can keep several cups warmed and ready to drink.
The Moccamaster is certainly not cheap but you’ll get a long-lasting and consistent machine that delivers top-tier coffee time after time from the comfort of home.
- Brew up a full, large carafe in little more than 5 minutes
- Powerful copper heating element to bring temperature rapidly up to the optimum band of 196 to 205 degrees Fahrenheit
- Class-leading 5-year warranty so buy with complete peace of mind
- A few complaints about brittle build quality
See Also: Top 7 Best Coffee Makers With Grinder
4. OXO Brew 9 Coffee Maker
Perhaps you like the idea of using the pour-over method but you don’t have the time or the patience to put it into practice?
Get the next best thing with this OZO Brew coffee maker. Once your coffee is all set, the double-walled stainless steel carafe keeps up to 9 cups piping hot so you’ve got some in reserve at all times.
How do you know if that stored, warmed coffee is past its best, though? OXO makes it easy with a freshness indicator telling you when it’s time to ditch the contents of the carafe and make a fresh brew.
Push-button simplicity lets you set the machine to kick in automatically and start brewing. Start coming down in the morning to the smell of fresh coffee permeating the kitchen and your caffeine fix ready to roll.
As a crowning bonus, the OXO comes certified by the SCA (Specialty Coffee Association) so you know you’re in safe hands.
- Makes from 2 to 9 cups of lip-smacking coffee replicating the cold brew method
- Keep a close eye on the freshness of coffee in the carafe thanks to the handy indicator on the LED display
- Occupies a reasonably small footprint so works well in smaller kitchens
- Some reported issues with leakage although we didn’t experience this during testing
5. Bonavita 8-Cup Coffee Maker with Thermal Carafe
This 8-cup coffee brewer from Bonavita brings ease of use to the fore and delivers a great brew every time with water at the ideal temperature.
If you’re baffled by tech and put off by complicated digital displays and too many bells and whistles, the Bonavita gives you everything you need and nothing you don’t. Simple push-button functionality married to an auto shut-off feature to keep safety uppermost means this is perfect for all users.
You can activate a pre-infusion mode if you’re a purist and want to degas your coffee beans before brewing.
Although the carafe is glass, it’s dishwasher-safe and with the hot plate factored in, you can keep coffee warm for up to 40 minutes fuss-free. If you fancy a stainless steel carafe, 2 variants of this coffee maker offer that option.
For a user-friendly all-rounder from a brand you can trust, this is a strong and reliable thermal carafe coffee maker.
- Potent 1500-watt heater brings the water swiftly between 195 and 205 degrees Fahrenheit for the perfect coffee
- Rugged and lined thermal carafe comes in stainless steel for added lifespan
- Oversized showerhead and flattened-out filter promote the ideal extraction
- While cheap, a few users have complained about build quality and problems developing soon after purchase
6. Cuisinart 12-Cup Coffee Maker with Thermal Carafe
Have you got a larger family to cater for? If so, this 12-cup thermal carafe coffee maker from Cuisinart is just what you’ve been looking for.
How about if you’re impatiently waiting for that substantial carafe to fill and you’re desperate for a quick cup? Just hit Brew Pause and you can draw your caffeine fix off mid-cycle, perfect for those super-busy mornings.
While you’ll get a fully programmable coffee maker, the Cuisinart is a cinch to use even if you’re not the biggest tech-lover.
Filling is simplified thanks to the transparent viewing window and clean-up is equally straightforward.
Choose from either regular or bold brews to taste so there’s something for all the family.
Don’t be fooled by the picture or the listing: the carafe is made from glass rather than stainless steel. This is not a deal-breaker but you should know what you’re getting. The bulk of the machine is indeed finished in stainless steel and this is still a rugged and durable unit.
- Generous capacity capable of making a full dozen cups of freshly brewed coffee
- Programmable through 24 hours for your complete convenience
- Self-cleaning to keep your upkeep to the bare minimum
- Some complaints about spilled coffee grounds
7. Zojirushi 10-Cup Coffee Maker
Perhaps best known for their rice cookers, Zojirushi also make a mean coffee machine and this 10-cup model is a fine example.
Get things started the right way with a piping hot 200 degrees Fahrenheit then ensure your drinks stay drinkable for longer thanks to the thermal carafe. This is fashioned from stainless steel and comes with vacuum insulation so you can avoid the harshness induced by a warming plate while keeping your coffee hot.
The permanent mesh filter is simple to clean and reusable. You can also remove the water tank to simplify cleaning and filling. The basket also lifts out when it’s time to clean up streamlining the whole procedure wonderfully.
The intelligent machine tweaks the ratio if you’re brewing iced coffee so you don’t end up with a weak and diluted travesty in your cup.
Programmable functionality allows you to ease into your day with a mouth-watering coffee ready to greet you as you head into the kitchen.
- Keep your brewed coffee hot and ready to drink for hours thanks to stainless steel thermal carafe
- Drip-prevention in place to stop splashing and spillage when you remove the carafe
- Iced coffee setting perfect for hot summer days
- Cleaning process is relatively awkward and requires citric acid
8. Cuisinart 10-Cup Thermal Coffee Maker
Another Cuisinart up next, this time a slightly smaller 10-cup model but again coming with a thermal carafe.
Choose from a striking array of color schemes if you’re tired of samey black and silver appliances glutting your kitchen.
You can tweak the temperature from regular to hot to extra-hot according to taste and brew up a full 12 cups. This will stay warm in the thermal carafe and you can also brew fewer cups if you don’t want or need the full monte.
With brew strength options, you can also ensure you get the depth and body you prefer and do the same for all the family.
Operation is straightforward while you’ll get plenty of tech-driven features enabling you to program your machine and enjoy coffee on demand. You can fine-tune auto shut-off up to a maximum of 4 hours giving you freedom and safety rolled into one.
Aversatile and substantial thermal carafe coffee maker from a highly reputable brand, this Cuisinart packs a serious punch.
- Available in a broad spread of colors to suit any kitchen décor
- Choice of temperature settings gives you coffee just the way you like it
- Completely automatic and programmable through 24 hours
- Unreliable customer service if you run into any problems
9. Mr Coffee 10-Cup Thermal Coffee Maker
If you think you can’t get a thermal carafe coffee maker on a budget, think again. Mr Coffee specialized in bringing highly effective machines into the home kitchen at a price to suit almost anyone.
With an onboard water filter, you can enjoy a crisper, cleaner drink.
The 10-cup capacity gives you ample coffee for a large and thirsty family. If you need to grab a quick cup before it’s ready, just hit pause and make that happen.
Both the water tank and filter basket slip out to simplify your cleaning efforts and there’s an automatic cycle to ensure you seldom need to lift a finger.
The stainless steel carafe keeps any residual coffee hotter for longer and there’s a 2-hour auto shut-off to slash energy costs while preventing any chance of an accident through overheating.
And the most incredible thing of all about this thermal carafe model? The price tag amounting to little more than a large round of drinks at Starbucks.
- Outstanding price/performance ratio
- Self-cleaning to keep maintenance to an absolute minimum
- Water filter helps keep all that unwanted chlorine in the water supply out of your coffee cup
- Some consumers have moaned about the carafe losing its warming ability over time
10. BLACK+DECKER 12-Cup Thermal Coffee Maker
To round out our hunt for the most effective coffee machine packing a thermal carafe, this 12-cup beast from BLACK+DECKER shows they can produce far more than power tools.
As with all the best large-capacity drip brewers, you can scale things down from a huge 12 cups to a more manageable 1 to 4 cups as required.
How about if you choose to brew up a larger quantity and can’t quite find room for it in a single sitting? The impeccably insulated carafe cuts any waste and allows you to keep the remaining coffee hot for several hours thanks to the double walls and vacuum seal in place.
Brew by tweaking the strength to your precise tastes and enjoy the performance of the patented Evenstream showerhead to get the optimum extraction every time.
Look out for any build-up of scale induced by hard water and follow the simple instructions for flushing the system using a solution of vinegar and water.
For an affordable and capable drip coffee maker with one of the best thermal carafes on the market, give the BLACK+DECKER a shot.
- Excellent 12-cup capacity so works well for larger families
- Double-walled and vacuum sealed carafe to keep the leftover coffee piping hot until you’re ready for more
- Wide mouth of carafe promotes easy clean-up
- Not the best lifespan but you need to peg your expectations at this price-point
Now we’ve wrapped our reviews, we’ll round out with some simple advice on what you should look for when you’re tracking down a thermal carafe coffee machine.
II. What to Look for in a Thermal Carafe Coffee Maker
Choosing a drip brewer with a thermal carafe is remarkably straightforward if you know what to look out for.
Double down on these elements and you can’t go wrong.
Think about how many people are crying out for coffee in the morning.
Capacity varies from a handful of cups at the lower end up to 12 cups with the bulkiest models.
If you’re going for a larger capacity carafe, think about 2 key factors beyond how many cups it makes…
Firstly, do you have enough room on the kitchen counter to accommodate the machine? It’s senseless angling for the largest machine you can afford if it ends up crowding or dominating your kitchen.
Beyond this, check to see if the machine has a brew pause function. This allows you to hit a button and stop the cycle before it’s done to snatch a quick cup. This can be extremely valuable if you’re always in a rush to get out the door in the morning.
Thermal or Glass Carafe?
Think closely about the materials of the carafe.
Glass carafes give a crisp taste and they’re light so easy to handle. On the flipside, they’re obviously fragile so need a careful touch. This type of carafe won’t normally retain heat in and of itself but will sit on a warming plate. The aftertaste imparted with this method tends to polarize opinion.
Stainless steel carafes, on the other hand, will often come with a vacuum seal and double-layered walls. This kind of carafe has the ability to keep coffee warm and ready to drink for several hours in the case of the best models. Stainless steel carafes are also much more rugged.
There’s no right or wrong choice here, simply the right option for you.
If you’re a coffee purist, you’ll appreciate that the finest cup always starts with freshly ground beans.
Perhaps you already have a grinder in the kitchen in which case you can skip this step.
If you don’t, some of the best coffee makers come with an onboard grinder. This is especially valuable if you’ve got a cramped kitchen and you want as many multipurpose appliances as possible.
Either way, do yourself a favor and start embracing the beauty of making coffee with freshly ground beans rather than pre-ground. You can thank us later.
Functionality and Programmability
Rather than looking out for the most feature-rich coffee maker, think instead about the functionality you’ll actually use.
Programmability is handy if you’re always dashing around in the morning and you want to come downstairs to the enticing smell of coffee brewing and a fresh carafe waiting for your attention.
More important than anything are the choice of drinks at your disposal and how you can manipulate strength and type.
Whether you prefer the simplicity of an analogue dial or a more complex digital interface, choose what works best for you and your family.
Last but by no means least, think about aesthetics.
While design should by no means be the deciding factor in your buying decision, it’s obvious that you should like the look of the coffee machine you’re buying.
The best thermal carafe models come in an array of colors and you can choose from all shapes and sizes.
Get what works well in your kitchen and you’ll be leaving it on the counter not hurrying to pack it away.
With any luck, you’ve now got a small but formidable shortlist of coffee makers giving you the functionality you need, capacity to suit and a carafe to keep any residual coffee warmed and ready to drink at a later stage.
Choosing the most effective model in this slim sub-niche is not particularly tough and boils down as much as anything to capacity and the construction of the carafe.
With those elements dialed in, think about how you like your coffee and determine whether or not the machine you’re looking at will enable you to achieve this.
Want more than just coffee? Look for a more versatile machine that lets you make tea, too.
If you’re also partial to a cold drink, many of these machines, while boasting thermal carafes to help you keep your coffee warmer, also come with the ability to make iced coffee. Some will even allow you to replicate the cold brewing method for still greater flexibility.
Bookmark our site here at The Prince LA and consider us your one-stop shop any time you need advice on the best products for your home. We cast the net wide and bring you the very strongest options for all rooms of the house without neglecting the garden either.
If you’ve got any questions just drop us a line any time. We’re highly responsive to messages and always happy to help out in any way we can.
Come back soon!